Official Forums > News & Announcements
Paperdoll Competition: Round 2 (Voting)
Pokemaster MAC:
Nothing personal to the three talented entrants, but I'm abstaining from voting this round. Why? I find too many things I disagree with on each of the 3 entries. I'm not going to explain which ones/why so I don't look like some Troll.
I will admit I'm disappointed because the previous round's renditions were better. I also take into account:
Higher difficulty
Less possible creativity
At this time, I'll be a good little boy and shut up.
genbor:
--- Quote from: Pokemaster MAC on July 03, 2012, 07:59:38 AM ---Nothing personal to the three talented entrants, but I'm abstaining from voting this round. Why? I find too many things I disagree with on each of the 3 entries. I'm not going to explain which ones/why so I don't look like some Troll.
I will admit I'm disappointed because the previous round's renditions were better. I also take into account:
Higher difficulty
Less possible creativity
At this time, I'll be a good little boy and shut up.
--- End quote ---
No problem, you didn't really have to state it, but thanks... Anyways I honestly think this round turned out better then the previous one for everyone.
John Flame:
I found it very hard to vote this round.
There wasn't 1 of them that spiked my attention,there were various,each with their downs and ups.
I'm just gonna say this before you read on,you might feel offended,for i am very "mean" in the way i say things,but if you will read,please know you are to be congratulated for most would not even get this far.
I liked the idea of Genbors Emo Kid and had my mind set on voting on it.But it seems i have a different interpretation of emo than most people do,i was expecting a black coat dude with a matching sombrero style hat,with a manuscript in his hand.
Then there was Monzta's King,when i think of a king,i do not aim myself at the classic pumpy bearded men dressed in gold and red.
Infact,i got more towards the prince look,the knight in his galliant armor,with his shield that keeps hope living on and his sword that punishes all those dark.So,i could not bring myself to vote here.
And finally,Lubbies Roman,this was by far the one i liked the most,from his starting schemes i never looked at it as a "chicken" perspective,and kept seeing a roman in there.In my pokémon roman,the only thing that his drawing lacks is the classic spear in the hand,and a separation from the chestplate and the gloves/bracers.If he showed skin between the shoulder and the lower arm,he would have got my vote from the start.Lubbies got my vote on this one.
P.S:I was deeply sad when i heard Amphi was not gonna participate anymore.I loved his fire type trainer to the core.
genbor:
I'm also going to leave this here to prevent further confusion: Please vote on quality, how well they stuck to the description, and originality.
Jerry:
I would say that you started the flame war by your post containing your 'thoughts' on the chars because I believe that Silver (and me as well) find that a lot of the things you 'thought' was totally off the focus of this poll.
You have the right to state your opinion, but the fact that you intentionally 'slapped them in the face' was uncalled for. Just saying
--- Quote ---I'm just gonna say this before you read on,you might feel offended,for i am very "mean" in the way i say things,but if you will read,please know you are to be congratulated for most would not even get this far.
--- End quote ---
is like saying sorry for intentionally killing someone.
If any of you have complaints about the sprites, then please SHOW us how you would have done those twice, thrice, or how many times you want, better.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version