Pokémon Discussion > General Chat

Which is better, gold & silver, diamond & pearl or black & white?

<< < (2/5) > >>

Hiteryan:
Never played Black/White. Seems great in terms of looks and gameplay but the Pokémon on it (which I barely know) from what I've seen just totally put me off.

I'd say HeartGold/SoulSilver. Two regions to explore, Johto has an awesome feel to it, the game has by far the best music in the series, and if you've played Red/Blue/Yellow it'll feel nostalgic to you to explore Kanto, and also to be able to catch most Pokémon from Gen 1.

Viper:
Uh Ruby and Sapphire are the best of course, how dare you not put them on the list.

Darkstar64:
If I were you, I would get Gold or Silver. It'll last you the longest and the game is well made.

CptMugwash:
Wow thanks for all the replies everyone.  It sounds like gold/silver are a good choice.  Ruby and Saphire what about them? what do they have?  And I didn't mind the 1st gen pokemon being like real animals as you could see them in rl.

Viper:

--- Quote from: CptMugwash on October 30, 2011, 07:40:02 PM ---Wow thanks for all the replies everyone.  It sounds like gold/silver are a good choice.  Ruby and Saphire what about them? what do they have?  And I didn't mind the 1st gen pokemon being like real animals as you could see them in rl.

--- End quote ---

Lets just say on my list of best pokemon games it goes like this:
1. Ruby/Sapphire
2. Black/White
3. Heartgold/Soulsilver
4. Diamond/pearl
5. Firered/leafgreen
6. Everything else

Now dont get me wrong the originals were good but they dont compare anymore to the remakes and new games. Why i like Ruby and Sapphire so much though is because the pokemon in it are my favorite and there is such diversity. The main reason i think i like it so much is because when it first came it was such a drastic improvement from the crappy graphics and gameplay of gold/silver that it blew my mind. When it came out i bought both games and spent 200+ hours getting the entire pokedex. I havent done that in another pokemon game since and i dont know why i havent. Anyway, most of my favorite pokemon come from that gen so it has always been my favorite in my eyes.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page